Skip to Main Content

Library & Information Services Sub Menu Dismiss

English 102: Quote Tracing

Narrative & Media Rhetoric

Narrative – a spoken or written account of connected events; a story.

Objective Reality is not subjective. It exists and does not change depending on who is looking at it. It’s what happened, regardless of what anyone may think. People looking at the same objective reality from different angles will, inevitably, see it differently.

Authorial Intention, as you may suspect, is what the author would like to convey through their writing.

Reader Interpretation is the impact this writing actually has on the reader.  It is important to note that sometimes a reader will interpret a piece of writing as the author intended it to be interpreted, and sometimes they will not.

Definitions

“Bias” - consciously or unconsciously viewing a word through a particular lens constructed by belief systems, experiences, and individual perspectives.

Both Authorial Intention and Reader Interpretation are rooted in perspective. The attitude and outlook of the person doing the writing, or the reading will impact what they think about the topic and why.

Rhetorical Situation” - the circumstance of an event that consists of an issue, an audience, and a set of constraints. In this case, the audience is us and the event is the speaker’s original words as they are translated through levels of interpretation.

Discussion

The purpose of this activity is to recognize how a quote can be taken out of context in subtle (and overt) ways. The goal is to locate a quote within a news article and trace it through multiple layers of context to discover how journalists’ interpretations of quotes impact our understanding of actual events and news.

Because quotations can be interpreted, it is important to examine the source in its original context so that we are in a better position to understand others’ interpretation and use of quotations. If we cannot locate the original context, the quotation’s authenticity should be in question.

If the original speaker is widely “quoted,” then locating a variety of interpretations from secondary sources can be valuable. Such work will enable us to understand and examine the larger picture and the social narratives.

Every aspect of a text is a choice made by its creators (the initial speaker and additional influencers). Therefore, it is important for us to analyze:

  • how a quote came to be (how it was created and by whom)
  • the influence additional circumstances have on that quote (for instance, how it was distributed and various contexts in which it might appear)
  • the effects of journalistic choices and subsequent factors that shape the quote

Narratives are the story in which objective realities merge with interpretations and intentions. In this activity, we will be examining the rhetorical situation between quotes and the journalist’s perspective of the situational context.

Bias can obscure what actually happened. Be critical thinkers about news sources you encounter vs. hearing a story that is told secondhand. Whenever possible, we should aim to find the original content, and use logic and reasoning to arrive at a conclusion.

Quotes are often used as evidence for particular claims. The same quote will sometimes be used as evidence for vastly different claims, even those that contradict each other. For this activity, we are not claiming that a speaker’s quote is factual or that a journalist’s interpretation is accurate. Here, the only fact is that the speaker did say the words and they were (hopefully) quoted accurately.

For this assignment, you are focusing on these key people in media:

  • Speaker - The direct source, the individual who is being quoted in the media.
  • Journalist - The person who is quoting the speaker in writing.

How to choose your news - Damon Brown

Creative Commons License